Fair loudness-based measures for live events
Explanation, setup, and instructions
2025-03-23
It is often required of sound mixers and sound system engineers at live events to operate the sound system within an enforced Sound Level Limit, expressed as an A weighted time-averaged sound level displayed in the FOH mix area.
The typical Lp, Aeq, 15 min limit is an accumulated equivalent sound level of minutes passed; not the present.
Our research paper[1] outlines the application of an existing audio signal metering system to help sound mixers and sound system engineers ensure compliance with sound level limits in the present.
[1] J. Digby and A. Hill, “Enhanced Sound Level Monitoring at Live Events by Measuring Audio Program Loudness,” 2024
It is commonplace for each segment of a live concert to be limited to a maximum time-averaged acoustic level, e.g.:
\(98 \text{ dB }\textit{L}_{\textit{p,} \text{Aeq,15}\textit{ min}}\)
Note
The above term specifies an accumulated average — \(\underline{\text{eq}}\)uivalent to a continuous
\(\underline{\text{A}}\)-weighted sound \(_\underline{\mathbf{\textit{p}}}\)ressure \(\underline{L}\)evel of \(\underline{98}\) \(\underline{\text{decibels}}\) over a rolling \(\underline{15}\) \(\underline{\text{minute}}\) period.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Figure A3.1 – Discrepancy in low-frequency contribution with A-weighted sound-level measurements.[2(p. 76)]
Concerts and events can use a Target Level loudness to optimize sound exposure within Sound Level Limits through the use of standard Audio Program Loudness Meters[1]
The result is real-time broadband loudness normalization, which offers a parallel benefit for stakeholders:
parity of loudness between acts and show elements, using a fair and psychoacoustically correct measure[3–5]
This is not the case when operating solely to an A weighted and time-averaged Sound Level Limit.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Normalization of a series of programmes
‘It is the average, integrated loudness of the whole programme that is normalised.’[6(p. 7)]
European Broadcasting Union, “TECH 3343: Guidelines for Production of Programmes in Accordance with EBU R 128.” EBU, Geneva, Nov. 2023
The shift from Peak normalization to Loudness normalization provides a consistent and predictable loudness and contrast across all program segments.
This allows an entire event’s audio presentation to function as an optimized and cohesive production, with improved sound quality and impact.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
An upper limit of:
100 dB Lp, Aeq,15 min
This is a feature of the World Health Organization’s 2022
Global Standard for Safe Listening Venues & Events.[2(p. 9)]
Note
The fair loudness-based measurement protocol can be calibrated to this limit using Brownian noise for easy integration of the WHO Standard.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Becoming an early adopter of the recently introduced Healthy Ears, Limited Annoyance (HELA) Certification is encouraged, as it’s hoped it will become the norm[7].
The HELA initiative is about education, and has the backing of big names in the industry.
Once staff complete the online training the individual and the event is certified, which benefits both.
‘It’s not about turning it down,
but a more comprehensive approach’
Dr Adam J Hill
See the HELA Initiative’s frequently asked questions
System 1;2;3 and Presenters Desk[1(p. 7)]
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Appropriate definitions, descriptions, strategies, and guidance should be taken from the following EBU documents:
Important
It is essential that all FOH operatives, production management and relevant stakeholders are informed about EBU R 128 in advance of the event to allow them time to prepare, discuss, and familiarize[1(p. 7)].
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
We need to apply an important exception to the R 128 Acoustical Alignment, Listening Level instructions in EBU TECH 3343[6(pp. 22–23)], as follows:
In our situation the Reference Listening Level of the loudspeaker reproduction setup is adjusted to ensure that any A weighted, C weighted, or octave-band Sound Level limits are not breached by a programme with a Maximum Loudness Level of –23,0 LUFS.
This is found by calibrating the sound system’s acoustic gain during propagation tests, and by monitoring the situation throughout.
The calibration procedure is covered in later slides of this presentation.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
An RME MADI interface with BNC takes Left/Right outputs of all mixing consoles from the Presenters Desk MADI output.
The connected PC displays an ITU 1770 / EBU R128 loudness meter for each console using RME’s Digicheck NG[16]
The PC’s HDMI output is used to feed its mirrored display to external monitors at each mixing console: e.g.
System 1;2;3 (stage), and Presenters Desk (PA system)
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
RME Audio, “DigiCheck NG.” RME Audio, Germany, Jan. 08, 2025[16]
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
This procedure differs from R 128 Acoustical Alignment, Listening Level instructions in EBU TECH 3343, pp. 22–23.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
A recommended type of test signal is broadband Brownian noise, as this has a frequency spectrum that approximates real musical material[1(p. 3),2(p. 87)].
These downloadable two-minute WAV files were prepared with Audacity audio editing software
(right-click, select ‘Save link as’ or similar):
Brownian Noise STEREO -23 LUFS non-coherent L&R 48 kHz.wav
Brownian Noise STEREO -23 LUFS non-coherent L&R 44,1 kHz.wav
Brownian Noise MONO -23 LUFS 48 kHz.wav
Brownian Noise MONO -23 LUFS 44,1 kHz.wav
The WAV files are also available for download at www.digbyphonic.com
It is the average, integrated loudness of the whole programme that is normalised.[6(p. 7)]
The master R 128 meter (i.e. PA system; Presenters Desk) should ‘start’ at the beginning of show, and ‘stop’ at the end (RME’s Total Time function). This represents the average, integrated loudness of the whole programme.[6(p. 41)]
For individual act consoles (i.e. System 1, System 2, etc.) the meter should ‘stop’ at the end of each act, and ‘start’ at the beginning of a line-check.
Sound mixers should refer to their R 128 meter and listen to the result; they need not concern themselves with chasing an SPL target.
Programme that does not exceed the loudness Target Level will likely not exceed the Lp, Aeq, T upper limit, provided the calibration and propagation steps have been completed correctly and circumstances have not changed.
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
–23,0 LUFS
For live programmes the accepted tolerance is ±1,0 LU at -23,0 LUFS
Tip
The Programme Loudness Level may be normalised to a Target Level lower than –23,0 LUFS on purpose[8(p. 3)].
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
| Programme Loudness | –23,0 LUFS |
| Maximum Short-term Loudness (S) | –18,0 LUFS (±5,0 LU on the relative scale) |
| Maximum True Peak Level | –1 dBTP |
| Loudness Range | (not applicable) |
Short-form content
“A programme of short duration (typically shorter than 30 seconds but up to approximately 2 minutes). In addition to advertisements (commercials) and promotional items, interstitials, stingers, bumpers and similar very short items also belong to this category.”[15(p. 4)]
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
Maximum Permitted True-Peak Level
−1 dBTP
Copyright 2025, Jonathan J Digby. This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-ND 4.0
The fair loudness-based measurement protocol is ideally suited to any event that wishes to follow safe listening guidelines†:
providing consistent and predictable loudness and contrast across all program segments.
with noticeable improvements in sound quality, impact, and the audience experience.
Tip
Ensuring that a headline act can play “louder” is straightforward and assured when using the loudness-based approach. See[2(p. 20)].
† This includes the recently introduced HELA initiative — Healthy Ears, Limited Annoyance certification for individuals, venues, and events.
If there’s to be a competition,
let it be a competition of quality
and not sound pressure level.
It isn’t necessarily the case that higher SPL equates to greater loudness, and vice versa.
The main benefit for stakeholders is parity of loudness across all show elements and acts – using a fairer, psychoacoustically correct measure.
It’ll be useful to calibrate an electrical signal to Lp, Aeq, T , but what may be more beneficial is the improvement in sound quality.
Please contact the author with any queries, suggestions, or insight:
Jonathan J Digby (Diggers); digbyphonic@gmail.com
A number of case studies using our research paper recommendations are planned for the summer of 2025.
The findings will be used to expand specific guidance for implementing our protocol.
Please contact the authors if you are interested in collaborating with us and using your event as a case study.
Jonathan J Digby — Email: digbyphonic@gmail.com
[NEXT SLIDE: → , ↓ , SPACE , N , L , J] [PREVIOUS SLIDE: ← , ↑ , P , H , K] [MENU: bottom left]